December 6, 2005

Review: LilyPod Microwavable Single Cup Coffee Pod Mug

Review from Single Serve - Coffee Pod Reviews P569-1We've been testing the LilyPod over the past several weeks and we'll say this right up front - results have been varied. The LilyPod Microwave Brew Mug supposedly brews up a nice cup of joe in 3 minutes or and that means less mess and the convenience of using whatever flavor pod you'd like to throw into it. The big factor here is the microwave.

Img 1651-1We have had less than stunning results with the Single Serve microwave but have had better results at our friends house. Each time we use the Lilypod with the exact directions and try a microwave the results have been different. It's like we're making microwave popcorn and not coffee, but we do believe it makes sense the results are so varied.

If you've ever cooked in a microwave oven anything like popcorn, perhaps a Lean Cuisine, or even poached some eggs - you'll know that finding the right power setting and time to cook is important for YOUR MICROWAVE. We have found this to be the case with the LilyPod. We simply could not find a great setting for our Microwave but did find some decent ones with other less powerful microwave ovens. That being said, the coffee produced each time was not great coffee.

Making a cup of LilyPod Coffee

Img 1653Img 1655The Lily pod features is a personal Pod Brewing System in an 8-oz mug. To make a cup of Lilypod coffee you turn the mug upside down, fill with water to the desired level and type of coffee you are making and put a pod in the base. Next you screw the base on and flip the mug over. There's a little ring you put on the top of the mug and then you set it in the microwave for 3 minutes (roughly for single serve coffee) and then microwave.

The inside of the cup has what appears to be aluminum or some coating that really heats up. The LilyPod is basically a little percolator pot. The water inside the outer ring of the coffee pod chamber brews into the coffee pod and then percs up into the main chamber.

You can do various things like putting in skim milk - etc. into the top chamber before brewing to make a latte - etc. They recommend frothing up to the brim - but we found results were better when we used less milk (these directions are provided as well).

We stuck to brewing up coffee with the 18 pods (Melitta One:One) coffee pods that came with the LilyPod. We did try Baronet Coffee Pods, Cool Beans Pods, and a Senseo pod or two - results were well all over the place. The best pod we had luck with was darker roast and really letting the coffee settle and cool before drinking (specifically the Love at First Sip Medium Roast Coffee Pods).

Img 1765Now we have tried 3.5 minutes, 2 minutes, 2.5 minutes at 50% power - all types. We also mixed these with a variety of water levels in the reservoir. The best results so far have been in smaller microwaves (our friends house) at 3 minutes 20 seconds or so and on the highest water mark.

Img 1766We found the less water we used and then tried to match the time to be less for less water resulted in really weak coffee. We simply could not get the mug to respond to the lower settings. The coffee pod would be very dried out like the mug simply heated up the water much faster then it took to extract any coffee from the pod.

The mug itself is also a factor. The big reason seems to be the amount of plastic the mug is made out of. After brewing about 10 cups of coffee and dumping just about half of the failures, the LilyPod started to wear in with less plastic taste.

Overall - even when we got a cup of coffee produced that looked less like brown water, the coffee was not that great. The coffee had a plastic taste and we couldn't shake the feeling we were drinking really bad office coffee. The coffee produced is so far below the Melitta One:One coffee we're wondering why Melitta would put something out like this when they have other amazing products.


Can you see how much we wanted this thing to work right out of the box? We put or best foot and mouth forward on the LilyPod. We can say the coffee we finally were happy with was on par with the Mr. Coffee home cafe, but certainly not the Melitta One: One and how could it be really? The LilyPod is a $19.99 kitchen gadget and the Melitta One:One is a very well designed single serve coffee maker.

We think if you like experimenting a bit with a coffee gadget - then the LilyPod may be for you. We don't think the LilyPod is a great gift to start someone off on Single Serve Coffee but it could be a great gift if you know someone who has the time and patience to try out 5-10 different methods to get their microwave oven and the LilyPod to work together on a less than great cup of coffee in the end.

We are going to give the LilyPod 1 out of 5 coffee pods. We could not get it to make coffee from our microwave and we got mixed results in other microwaves, but we could get a rather bad cup of coffee if the planets were in alignment. So it's possible that your microwave, the pods you choose, and the LilyPod might agree to all work together - but we aren't going to hold our breath here at Single Serve

Lilypod Review Melitta

At Melitta

Read More in: Coffee Cups & Travel Mugs | Melitta One:One | Reviews

Share this Article with others: social bookmarking

Related Articles:

Came straight to this page? Visit Single Serve Coffee for all the latest news.

Posted by Jay Brewer at December 6, 2005 8:05 AM
Recent Comments

I think that you guys have strayed from the directions a little too far. This machine makes incredible servings of coffee "especially juan valdes dark" pods. You seem to have been judging your attempts at different water levels when you could have had some better results by trusting in the design. this machine has been a smash hit with people, and i think that something was definitely wrong with your situation. I am still in shock with this review. doesn't sound right.
john- chicago

Posted by: john at December 14, 2005 9:58 PM

I set the microwave at 3:30 100% and let it go. I have been using the max water level. It seems to work ok for me. I also pour the finished coffee into another mug. Drinking from that monster is a challenge. The Melitta coffee is less than impressive from the mug or the 1:1. My best guess is that you need to heat the water to build steam pressure to drive the hot water through the filter and up the spout/handle and into the cup. So, the more water the better.

Posted by: Ken at December 6, 2005 10:30 PM

Thanks for the extensive review, folks.

I've been eagarly awaiting a review for this product since you first mentioned it last month. Your findings are disappointing -- I certainly won't waste money on this little gadget.

Maybe someone someday may find a simpler, more fulfilling solution.

What a bummer.

Posted by: Bob at December 6, 2005 3:18 PM
Post a comment

Remember personal info?

Please enter the letter "t" in the field below:
Please press Post only once. Submission of comments takes up to 20 seconds because of Spam Filtering.
Join the Mailing List Mailing List
Enter your Email

Subscribe - RSS

facebook_badge.jpg twitter_badge.jpg

Recent Reviews
Recent Comments
Ruthell Bryson : What is URL: read more
Nate: Weswitched to a Remington iCoffee. They do not claim that read more
Nate: Where is the $5 sample deal? I've clicked everything that read more
AO: I agree with Nate. Keurig is a total joke when read more
Bob Boisen: I solved my K500's white-screen-of-death (aka 'oops') problem by opening read more
SSC Forums


This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.

Visit our other properties at!

All items Copyright © 1999-2017 Blogpire Productions. Please read our Disclaimer and Privacy Policy